Home
Old Index
The Dragon's Scepter
In Media Res
|
|
| Our Humble Archives | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Skwid | Pandabob | T-Rex | |||
| VeggieSteph | Rachelle | ||||
The Library of Babel
Outside of a Dog
Pam's Book Log
Shards of Delirium
Shih
The Tufted Shoot
Weasel Words
Blarg?
Boing-Boing
GA Guru
Guru2
The Little Professor
Lundblog & Lundblogblog
Making Light
Musical Perceptions
Pandabob
Peeps!
Peg-Leg Pete
Squidblog
Uncertain Principles
Unmistakable Marks
UselessBlogging
VeggieSteph
The Wildebeest Asylum
YellowText
October 2005 S M T W T F S 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Content Copyright 2005 by Evan "Skwid" Langlinais unless otherwise noted.
All rights reserved.
![]()
Powered by gm-rss
Livejournal RSS
[Previous entry: "The Forever War"] [Next entry: "Rex Mundi, Volumes 1 & 2"]
Thoughts on Altered Carbon:
Scott Spiegelberg (October 27th, 9:50 AM):
The cortical stack concept sounds very similar to Doctorow's mind backups in Down and Out...
How does Altered Carbon compare to Doctorow's work?
Skwid (October 27th, 10:31 AM):
Well, the basic concept is similar, but the implementation is really quite different. For one thing, Morgan doesn't assume a hippie cultural revolution leading to the abandonment of traditional currency, so while the implantation of cortical stacks is government funded (and effectively universal), backups and new sleeves are something you need to pay for in most cases.
And as I mentioned, backups for most folks aren't cheap or automatic, so your average joe has a bit more to lose than the few hours a billionaire with built-in satellite relay does. Doctorow's ubiquitous cloning tech also means that you don't have to adapt to a new body, and Morgan explores quite a bit how even if your brain works the same (which raises, to me, some fundamental issues...but I digress) a lot of our emotional responses are heavily influenced (if not governed entirely) by the "body" part of our nervous system.
Also, rather than handwaving away the folks with religious concerns about the soul's connection to the body as readily dying off, Morgan incorporates them thoroughly (Catholics, specifically, play an important role in the plot).
So I'd have to say that while they use some similar mechanisms, they're using them to explore different principles and ideas, which is what we're looking for from SF, right?
Mike Kozlowski (October 27th, 5:22 PM):
So I've heard people recommend this book, but it looked kinda bad -- all cyberpunky and generic. Perhaps now I'll check it out.
Skwid (October 28th, 8:13 AM):
It is kinda cyberpunky, but it rises above generic, I think. I wish I could recommend it more heartily to you, Koz, but occasionally our tastes just do not jive.